I have heard an expression many times throughout my life, “Potemkin Villages.” I looked it up to understand the precise origin, and it appears to be from Russia circa 1900. The definition I most recently found — and had definitely seen before — was that a Russian empress was visiting an area, and a fake village was constructed to make the area appear inhabited when it wasn’t actually. This term seems particularly salient today, when many companies are exploiting aspects of rules so as to appear more lucrative than traditional measures indicate. This brings to mind an expression I know related to economics, “a measure can be useful until it is a target.” My own personal belief is that in a quest to exploit increasingly minor discrepancies, people have taken to attempting to redefine broadly agreed upon beliefs so as to realize advantages.
Today is the day one of the big “AI” companies goes public, bringing this phenomenon to the foreground, as it engages in numerous gimmicks to artificially inflate its stock price. Here is an example: the number of shares available (the “float,” I think) is much lower than the number of potential buyers. Ergo, the price rises, and the IPO is considered “oversubscribed.” Potemkin demand! It seems like people are eager to buy it, but that’s merely because the available supply has been intentionally set below the level of demand.
The artificially low supply is certainly not the only factor here. Indeed, there is a far more insidious element. The business press is quite often a cheerleader for companies rather than being an investigator. One can legitimately point to numerous reasons for this, but at the end of the day, the business press, especially on television, behaves a lot more like PR than like news. Whereas news was something done for “the public interest” throughout the twentieth century, the focus of twenty-first century journalism in the US has very much shifted to helping hype companies that may have once been investigated. In this way, “the news” is much more like a hall of mirrors at a carnival, as every story is a deliberate misrepresentation.
Distorting perceptions does seem to be an inevitability for “the free market.” Humans seem far more malleable and resilient than markets, which are much more mechanical. Ergo, it seems inevitable that one group of market participants will eventually seek to deceive other market participants in order to gain an advantage. Come to think of it, I think this is essentially the plot of The Music Man. That the big “AI” company execs muse about ending humanity really makes the point. Much like a heroin addict seeks ever more heroin, these execs need to sell a vision that is increasingly intense. However, as part of that vision, they need to manufacture consent. So instead of offering only a vision of dystopia, it could be “abundance” for everybody — heaven on Earth. All anybody knows is that you’ll either get heaven or hell, but ya gotta buy.